2022-02-02 City Council Item No. 11.1 2022-2027 Consolidated Plan & Analysis of Impediments Community Outreach Results Presentation Regular MEETING - Additional Meeting Materials2022-2027
Consolidated Plan
& Analysis of
Impediments
Community
Outreach Results
What is a Consolidated Plan
•The Consolidated Plan (ConPlan) is designed to aid the city in assessing affordable housing and
community development needs
•The ConPlan helps determine how funds from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban
Development (HUD) are used
The consolidated planning process:
Ensures the programs are data-driven and place-based
Analysis of housing and economic market conditions
Addresses the priority needs and City’s goals Submission to HUD for review and approval
Outreach, Organization meetings, Data-gathering Analysis of Impediments Strategic Plan
Consolidated Plan
Completed
Data/Outreach
Community Outreach
Committee Meeting
Surveys/Data
These identified needs
are then used to form
the Strategic Plan
which informs and
guides the City’s Action Plan
(i.e., projects and
programs )
Helps the City identify
high-priority needs for the 2022-2027
Consolidated Plan
The results of the:
Community Outreach
•Community feedback is required by HUD for the Consolidated Plan
•This helps the City identify the most urgent needs and ensures those needs are aligned with the projects that
obtain CDBG funding
•Interviews with Organizations that
operate within the City of Menifee
and partnering communities
•Organizations such as:o Housing providers
o Health services
o Social services
o Organizations representing protected classes
o Fair housing
o Broadband internet providers
o Emergency management
organizations
Online Community Survey Public Outreach Organizations
•Survey was open from September
2021 to November 2021
•Two community surveys launched
September
o One in English
o One in Spanish
•538 responses
•City’s Web Page
•Email blast to 375+ organizations
•Social Media
•Menifee Matters
•Motte’s Museum Mtg.
•Quail Valley Mtg.
Organization Interviews
Some of the organizations we are speaking with are:
•Boys & Girls Club
•Riverside County Fair Housing Council
•Hospice of the Valleys
•Family Service Association
•Lake Menifee Women’s Club
•Menifee Valley Chamber of Commerce
•Habitat for Humanity Inland Valley
•Veterans of Foreign Wars
We have reached out to 41 organizations to get
feedback
The purpose of speaking with these
organizations is to get input on what
specialized needs may exist in the City of
Menifee that CDBG funding could assist
with.
Organizations work closely with community
members and can give us personalized
insight on issues of concern to these
communities.
Survey Results
33%
66%
Gender
Male Female
1.12%
19.78%
32.09%
16.23%
12.31%
15.30%
1.31%1.87%18-2425-3435-4445-5455-6465-8080+Prefer not to sayAge
54.10%
7.46%
30.41%
3.92%1.49%0.37%
11.01%White or CaucasianBlack or AfricanAmericanHispanic or LatinoAsian or AsianAmericanAmerican Indian orAlaska NativeNative Hawaiian orother Pacific IslanderPrefer not to sayRace/ethnicity
86%
15%
Homeowner vs. Renter
Homeowner Renter
Housing
28%
10%14%
32%31%
15%
4%
9%
48%
31%31%
17%
10%8%Homeowner Housing RehabilitationHousing AccessibilityImprovementsAmerican Disability Act (ADA)ImprovementsAffordable Rental HousingSenior HousingHousing for the DisabledLead-Based Paint Test/AbatementRehabilitation of ApartmentBuildingsEnergy Efficiency ImprovementsHousing Code EnforcementDown Payment AssistanceSupportive Housing*Low-barrier Housing**Other (please specify)Top three housing programs that the City of Menifee should consider for the 2022-2027 Consolidated Plan cycle.
58%
42%
Is affordable housing available to you and your family?
Yes No
Community Facilities/Services
25.31%
62.41%
35.38%
54.79%
12.53%
37.84%
31.20%28.50%
8.85%Senior CentersYouth CentersNeighborhood FacilitiesParks and Recreational FacilitiesAmerican Disability Act (ADA)Improvements to existing facilitiesChild Care CentersHealth FacilitiesCultural CentersOther (please specify)Top three community facilities you believe the City of Menifee should consider for the 2022-2027 Consolidated Plan cycle.
34.73%
15.76%
48.03%
34.24%32.27%
18.23%16.01%
8.62%7.39%4.19%
31.03%
19.46%
14.53%
22.17%
2.96%Senior ServicesDisabled ServicesYouth ServicesTransportation ServicesCrime AwarenessDomestic Violence ServicesSubstance Abuse ServicesTemporary SheltersFair Housing CounselingTenant/Landlord CounselingChild Care ServicesHealth ServicesServices for Very Low IncomeHomeless ServicesOther (please specify)Top three community/special needs services you believe the City of Menifee should consider for the 2022-2027 Consolidated Plan cycle.
Homeless Needs
50.74%48.51%46.53%
18.07%11.88%
79.21%
12.13%Food and clothingEmergency sheltersTransitional housingPermanent housingOne-time rental assistanceMental health/ addiction servicesOther (please specify)Top three homeless needs that you believe the City of Menifee should consider for the 2022-2027 Consolidated Plan Cycle.
Economic Development
48.88%
31.76%
53.85%59.06%
70.97%
12.41%Rehabilitation ofCommercial BuildingsFaçade ImprovementsEmployment TrainingSmall Business LoansJob CreationOther (please specify)Top three business needs that you believe the City of Menifee should consider for the 2022-2027
Consolidated Plan cycle.
Infrastructure
41.77%
77.15%
43.24%
31.20%
17.44%22.85%
38.08%
17.20%Increased CodeEnforcementStreet ImprovementsSidewalkImprovementsPedestrian CrosswalksParking FacilitiesSewer/Storm DrainImprovementsStreet LightingImprovementsOther (please specify)Top three infrastructure needs that you believe the City of Menifee should consider for the 2022-2027 Consolidated Plan cycle.
Social Services
47%
26%21%
15%14%15%15%19%16%
29%
22%
14%12%13%16%
24%
6%11%
3%After-school programs and/or summer day campfor childrenPrograms for at-risk youthChildcareCounseling/emotional supportDisaster and emergency preparedness measuresDrug/alcohol abuse counseling/treatmentFood or meals for residents with special needsJob training and/or placementLow-cost transportation services (Dial-A-Ride/City Lines)Neighborhood crime prevention programsPark and recreation programsSupport for affordable housingPublic arts programsRevitalization of deteriorated commercial areasServices and shelter for homeless peopleSpecial events, festivals & community gatheringsLegal aid/servicesHealth care servicesOther (please specify)Top three social services that you feel should receive financial support from the City of Menifee.
Broadband Needs
64.95%
16.67%18.38%
Yes No Don't know
Do you believe there are common/pressing broadband internet problems (e.g., high-speed connectivity availability, diversity of providers) in the City of Menifee?
18.63%
37.99%
43.38%
Yes No Don't know
Do you feel that low-and moderate-income areas have adequate broadband access?
Where We Are
Ensures the programs are data-driven and place-based
Analysis of housing and economic market conditions
Addresses the priority needs and City’s goals
Allows the jurisdiction to track its accomplishments
Outreach,
Organizations meetings, Data-gathering
Analysis of Impediments Strategic Plan
Annual Action Plan/
CAPER
Final edits to the Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing
What is an Impediment?
Impediments to fair housing choice are:
•Any actions, omissions, or decisions that directly restricts or have the effect of
restricting housing choices or housing availability because of:
o Race
o Color
o Religion
o Sex
o Disability
o Familial status
o National origin
o Financial status
The AI is a required component of the City’s Consolidated Plan
Examples of Impediments
•Discriminatory lending practices
•Access to opportunities (i.e., access to quality
schools)
•Housing discrimination (i.e., marketing language
implying discrimination)
•Land use policies and procedures (i.e., availability
of senior housing, emergency shelters)
•Collaborating regionally (i.e., working with regional
organizations to address issues such as
homelessness within the City)
Housing Discrimination
8.00%
2.75%
8.75%7.00%
32.25%
6.00%
35.25%Yes, I haveI think I may haveI haven't, but someoneI know hasI haven't, but I think Imay know someonewho may haveI'm not surePrefer not to sayOther (please specify)Have you encountered housing discrimination?
17.28%17.04%
9.14%
21.73%
33.09%
1.73%
Yes Likely Unlikely No Don'tknow Prefernot tosay
Do you believe housing discrimination occurs in the City?
38.50%
16.31%
5.88%
16.31%
5.35%
11.23%
19.25%
40.37%
11.50%Race/Ethnicity Religion DisabilitySexual OrientationPregnant or Having Children Sex/GenderAgeMarital StatusNational Origin/Ancestry Family StatusCriminal History/Record Source of IncomeNone, I do not think there is any housingdiscrimination in the CityOther (please specify)What types of discrimination do you think are most prevalent?
Next Steps
Outreach, Stakeholder meetings, Data-gathering
Analysis of Impediments Strategic Plan
Consolidated Plan Completed
Addressing the priority needs and
City’s goals